Daily DispatchDaily Dispatch
JO

Creator

Jonathan Goldberg

WORKWISE | WhatsApp retirement message costs employer R120,000

The Labour Court in Durban has confirmed that dismissing an employee via a messaging app on the basis of age constitutes an automatically unfair dismissal, particularly when no agreed retirement age exists. In Lemmer v Dr Niresha Mudlay,…

Workwise | Double jeopardy principle central in labour appeal court ruling

The Labour Appeal Court has delivered a landmark ruling confirming that employers cannot discipline workers twice for the same conduct. In a matter involving Gert Sibande District Municipality and an accountant represented by SAMWU, the…

Premium

WORKWISE | Breakdown in trust made reinstatement intolerable

The Labour Appeal Court has overturned a Labour Court decision reinstating a senior manager, finding an irretrievable breakdown of trust rendered continued employment intolerable.

Premium

WORKWISE | LAC clarifies difference between procedural and substantive unfairness

The Labour Appeal Court has clarified that procedural flaws in a disciplinary process do not render a dismissal substantively unfair, overturning a Labour Court reinstatement order.

Global Business Solutions CEO Jonathan Goldberg.  SUPPLIED

WORKWISE | Employer's intoxication claim falls short in Labour Court

The Labour Court has dismissed an application by Unilec SA to overturn a CCMA award that ruled a worker's dismissal for alleged workplace intoxication was both procedurally and substantively unfair. Reaffirming that the burden of proof…

Global Business Solutions CEO Jonathan Goldberg.  SUPPLIED
Premium

Workwise | High court clarifies scope of workplace accidents

The High Court ruled that injuries sustained while exiting the workplace can qualify for compensation under COIDA, emphasizing a generous, fact-specific approach to determining if accidents arise from employment.

Global Business Solutions CEO Jonathan Goldberg.  SUPPLIED

WORKWISE| Plea bargains in the workplace: LAC clarifies limits

The Labour Appeal Court ruled that disciplinary chairpersons are not bound by workplace plea bargains, but fair procedure requires allowing employees to withdraw guilty pleas if agreed sanctions are rejected.

Global Business Solutions CEO Jonathan Goldberg.  SUPPLIED

Workwise | Zero-Tolerance Doesn’t Mean Automatic Dismissal

The Labour Court ruled that zero-tolerance alcohol policies cannot override fairness. Dismissal for a positive test is not automatic; circumstances, proportionality, and proper procedures must always be considered.

Global Business Solutions CEO Jonathan Goldberg.  SUPPLIED

WORKWISE| Refugee status lapse made employment unlawful, court finds

The Labour Court upheld an employee’s dismissal after his refugee status lapsed, confirming it was lawful and fair, despite arbitration irregularities, as continued employment would have been illegal.

Global Business Solutions CEO Jonathan Goldberg.  SUPPLIED
Premium

WORKWISE | LAC confirms dismissal settlement was full and final

The Labour Appeal Court had to consider a case which revolved around whether a settlement agreement reached at the CCMA covered all claims arising from a termination

Global Business Solutions CEO Jonathan Goldberg.  Picture: SUPPLIED

WORKWISE | LAC upholds restraint of trade ruling

Ruling clarifies that a restraint agreement remains valid even after an employee’s dismissal.

Global Business Solutions CEO Jonathan Goldberg.  Picture: SUPPLIED

WORKWISE | Labour court upholds dismissal over dishonesty in promotion interview

The labour court ruled on whether the employee’s dismissal was substantively and procedurally fair

The main charge against her was gross insubordination for failing to return to the company’s Cape Town office on 13 June 2022, after being instructed to do so. File photo

Labour Court agrees with CCMA ruling of unfair dismissal

The Labour Court upheld a CCMA ruling that Medici Energy’s dismissal of an employee for not returning to the office was unfair, finding the instruction unreasonable and the process procedurally flawed.

The Labour Court set aside the CCMA award and referred the matter back for arbitration before a different Commissioner. File photo

Labour Court clarifies CCMA powers in dismissal review

In this weekly column, labour lawyer Jonathan Goldberg, chair of Global Business Solutions, looks at various aspects of labour law

In this weekly column, labour lawyer Jonathan Goldberg, chair of Global Business Solutions, looks at various aspects of labour law

Private note sparks court battle over dismissal

This ruling underscores the importance of proper procedure in arbitration, especially where dismissal is at stake.