A former editor of the Sunday Times once wrote a hilarious column that touched on the diplomatic nightmare state visits to Japan would be if Tokyo Sexwale were to ever become president. It’s simple, he would have had to drop that ridiculous moniker and revert to his birth name, Gabriel Mosima. That was in 2012, when the billionaire businessman and freedom fighter tried to challenge for ANC leadership. Branches rejected him so badly; he ended up on the slate of Kgalema Motlanthe in Mangaung as deputy president candidate and was trounced by Cyril Ramaphosa, who was on the Jacob Zuma slate for the same position. How things have changed.
After watching Sexwale again embarrass himself, this time on national TV, saying money from a “heritage fund” held in the Reserve Bank had been stolen (turns out he could be the victim of an internet scam operating under the delicious name “White Spiritual Boy”), we are relieved that his gazillion attempts at becoming president have all fallen flat. For crying out loud, the man was fooled by a blatant money scam that even Zuma recognised was a cheap gimmick.
But this got me thinking. What should be the criteria for public office? Should there be mandated minimum qualifying standards for MPs, MPLs and municipal councillors? If so, what should those standards entail? Should educational qualifications be a prerequisite for public office? Do wealth and struggle credentials make an individual suitable for the highest office in the land?
It’s not just Sexwale I’m directing this at. There are some who point to Zuma’s lack of formal education as probably the main contributor to his poverty of morals. Is it? Robert Mugabe was said to be the most educated president on Earth. How then do we explain his destruction of Zimbabwe in near four decades of misrule?
Do formal educational qualifications instil leadership acumen in their holder? Would an educated president be less inclined to steal from his/her people than an uneducated one? Does an educated leader have more respect for human rights?
Section 47 of the constitution stipulates that “every citizen who is qualified to vote for the national assembly is eligible to be a member of the assembly”. This means everyone in this country has a right to stand for public office regardless of their educational attainment, financial status or experience. Political parties generally adhere to this stipulation when compiling lists of potential candidates for public office. That is why I found it hilarious that some DA leaders felt the need to embellish their CVs with non-existent qualifications when this is not a requirement for public office. Just say you have matric, ma’am; you are in good company in that parliament. Others didn’t go that far; some don’t even know the inside of a classroom.
The compilers of our constitution were correct, though. It would have been wrong, undemocratic and elitist to exclude people from representing their communities because they did not go to university. Not in a country where education is so skewed in terms of quality and where access to higher education is prohibitively expensive. But it is not wrong to ask political parties to evaluate the quality of the people they nominate for public office and eliminate those who do not make the grade.
When I was a parliamentary correspondent I was shocked by the quality of some of the people sent to that august institution by their parties. Contrary to what you see on TV, MPs do not spend all their time yelling at each other or napping in the national assembly. The core work of parliament takes place in committee rooms — its engine room — where government departments and state institutions account for the money allocated to them. These departments and institutions compile highly technical financial and strategic reports that MPs have to read, understand and interrogate. State departments and institutions often send highly educated bureaucrats and executives to parliament to account.
I would watch in horror as departments got away with near murder because some MPs in a particular committee simply did not have the capacity to comprehend the complex information in front of them. They would either keep quiet or ask questions that were totally irrelevant to the presentations. Only a handful of MPs would interrogate and ask probing questions that enhanced accountability.
So in as much as you don’t need a higher education qualification to become president, MP or councillor, these crucial jobs still require a certain level of logic, cognisance, comprehension, moral astuteness and leadership capability. Democracy demands this. Ordinary Joes and daft billionaires must be automatically disqualified.